For over a decade now, I’ve been (very slowly) putting together a series of mixtapes that I call Instrumental Underdogs: unassuming collections of instrumental songs that I think are special. My only rule is that I can’t work to make them quickly; they’ve gotta just assemble themselves organically, at their own pace, with me just iteratively adding anything I hear in the wild that feels like an instrumental underdog. The tracklist gets shaped gradually, over years, without me ever really feeling like I’m working on it.
I really love it as a project. Around once a year, somebody messages me to say that they’ve been listening to one or other of the mixes and really enjoying them, and that feels like the perfect amount of ‘out in the world’ pride I get to feel about them. I’m such a language person, forever obsessed with finessing words to string thoughts from mind to mind – but there are simply places inside us that words don’t reach.
Instrumental Underdogs Vol. 1 (2009)

- Satyajit Ray – Bhupati and Amal
- Raymond Scott – Portofino 2
- The Microphones – The Breeze
- Michael Andrews – What’s That Sound?
- Elizabeth Cotten – Spanish Flang Dang
- The Motor Totemist Guild – In Sackloth and Ashes
- Mark Isham – Excerpt from the Times of Harvey Milk
- Tirath Singh Nirmala & Richard Youngs – Untitled
- Trouble Books – Drum Kit Drifts Off
- Bugskull – Communication
- Black Moth Super Rainbow – From the See
- Do Make Say Think – A Tender History in Rust
- Architecture in Helsinki – Rendesvous: Potrero Hill
Instrumental Underdogs Vol 2 – The Space Between Breaths (2014)

- Lehmann B. Smith – Piano (Dribble)
- Grant Green – We’ve Only Just Begun
- lee (asano +ryuhei) – 14.de a u.
- Harry Forbes – Remote Control
- Joe Meek & The Blue Men – The Bublight
- Jürgen Müller – Meeresblatt Meditation
- The Microphones – Organs and Pianos from “The Moon”
- Nuno Canavarro – –
- filthy ingredients – bloss kolta
- Blithe Field – Home Now
- Ashley Eriksson – March of the Conch
- Future Islands – Open
- William Allaudin Mathieu – Music for Honey-Bee Dancing
- En Passant – EP3
- Jack Armstrong & Chevy Chase – The Cott
Instrumental Underdogs Vol. 3 – And Now She Knows She’ll Never Be Afraid (2015)

- Hans-Joachim Roedelius, Stefan Schneider – Mild
- Virginia Astley – Summer of Their Dreams
- Nuno Canavarro – bruma
- Trouble Books – Unfolded
- Bugskull – Old Towne
- Lejsovka & Freund – From Royal Ave
- Galo Cantou – birdbird & Intame
- Chalices of the Past – Peace Noodle
- The Microphones – Instrumental
- Blithe Field – Dissolve & Reform
- Black Mother Super Rainbow – Colorful Nickels
- lee (asano+ryuhei) – ltr >>> thx
Instrumental Underdogs Vol. 4 – Ways of Being Alone (2020)

- Green-House – Sansevieria
- Tri Atma – Neverending
- Dustin Wong – Fourth of July BQE
- Electrelane – You Make Me Weak At The Knees
- Yo La Tengo – The Sea Horse
- Larry Goldings – Rain Street
- Eric Sahlstrom – Byggnan
- The Rubies – Four Gears
- The Durutti Column – Pol in B
- Blithe Field – PUMC
- K. Leimer – (Aka Accident)
- Suzanne Kraft – Flatiron
- Syrinx – December Angel
- Bugskull – Victory Lapse
- Sean McKeon & Conor Gay – Marbha Luimni
- Moondog – Pastoral
Instrumental Underdogs Vol. 5 – Cypro World (2023)

- El Conejo – Cigarras & Mariposas
- Cole Pulice – City in a City
- Lumtz – cada primera vez
- Dan Deacon – Pelican
- Rosen & Spyddet – Freja
- tino – gravity hill
- Lionmilk – talk to me
- Yo La Tengo – Sea Urchins
- x.y.r – bon voyage
- Omni Gardens – Iridescent Glint Beetle
- Young Marble Giants – This Way
- Jack Jutson – Loose Truth
- Kenji Kihara – In the Park
(Note: all the album art is taken from illustrations by Béatrice Appia (1899-1999), and mostly from Histoire de Perlette (1936), an insanely gorgeous picture book that I’m obsessed with.)